Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 20th July 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Council demolishes city store



View Video
Download Video

Video

Watch Edinburgh City Council bulldozers demolish Jaswant Singh's store.
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 08 April 2008
JASWANT SINGH is well used to arriving at his shop to find it has been attacked by vandals.
The shopkeeper was forced to rebuild his Niddrie Mains Drive business completely when it was destroyed by fireraisers, only to watch as it was burnt out again in February, just days before it was due to reopen.

But any hopes he had of resurrecting his business again have been well and truly demolished – after he turned up yesterday to find the city council knocking it down.

The move followed months of negotiations during which the Singhs refused to leave the site, despite the council wanting to pull down the building, which is the last one standing for hundreds of yards.

Mr Singh, 57, who lives in Portobello, insists the first he knew of the work was when he arrived to see a bulldozer ripping into the building.

In a desperate attempt to save his shop he darted behind the security fencing and stood in front of the building. An angry confrontation with the workmen followed before Mr Singh finally gave in and the demolition continued.

The council today insisted it had notified Mr Singh that this would happen, but he maintained the only communication he received was that the building was considered dangerous.

He said: "This is just unbelievable. That shop belongs to me and they have gone in without even telling us.

"The first I knew of this was when I drove round the corner to see a bulldozer destroying my shop."

After a fire in 2006, Mr Singh and his wife Shindo worked to restore the shop in the estate – most of which has been flattened under a regeneration programme.

Just before they were due to reopen the premises in February another fire ripped through the building, destroying everything inside again. But the couple vowed to remain in Niddrie and Mr Singh said they had been determined to see the shop – which they originally opened in 1985 – reopen.

Mr Singh added: "First we have had two fires and no-one around here seems to know what happened to start them.

"Now I turn up to see my own shop being destroyed."

Mrs Singh added: "Now any evidence that could have told us who started the fire has been destroyed.

"Our life's work is being ruined before us. We had a letter from the council saying they thought the building was unsafe, but there was no suggestion that this would happen."

A spokeswoman for the council said: "Following a serious fire at this address, the police and fire brigade expressed concerns about the condition of the property.

"Council officers carried out an assessment of the condition of the property and this led to it being classed as a dangerous building that would have to be demolished. Mr Singh was notified of this in early March."

The Singhs have long been in negotiation with the council over what should become of the shop. A compensation package was previously rejected by the Singhs, who said they would not be forced out of the area.


The full article contains 515 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 08 April 2008 2:05 PM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Evening News video archive
 
1

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

08/04/2008 12:15:51
Hmm. Some great pictures on this site of Niddrie through the years and the demolish(ment).

http://niddrie.tripod.com/index.html

see if you can find Mrs Singh (Wheres waldo)
2

Rambo_the_Jambo,

Edinburgh 08/04/2008 12:17:46
The shop was condemned property and a danger to others. He was offered compensation for the loss of his property but refuesd. So what's his problem?

Why is this a story?

3

gods lovechild,

08/04/2008 12:18:28
another one bites the dust eh !!!
4

Rambo_the_Jambo,

Edinburgh 08/04/2008 12:19:38
# 1 The Genuine Mario Antoinette

She's operating the digger, he hasn't seen her yet!!

She's thinking 'F. this anything to get out of Niddrie'.
5

Boy Wonder,

08/04/2008 12:29:12
The rest of the area is gone!! Who were thay going to sell goods to??

When did the refurbishment happen? Did anyone see it going on?

Looks like a scam to howk more cash out of the council me!
6

Louie the Dip,

08/04/2008 12:39:18
Demolish the whole of Niddrie & build "affordable housing" that the old residents cannot afford.

Well done the Council.
7

GraemeH,

Edinburgh 08/04/2008 12:53:57
If it was demolished because it was unsafe, why is he being offered compensation? His insurance should pay out for that.
8

Tricky Dickie ,

08/04/2008 13:02:31
#7

it was also a sh#t hole!!
9

Who let the dogs out?,

08/04/2008 13:35:36
he has the opportunity to escape from Niddrie, i would take the money and run
10

,

08/04/2008 13:58:19
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
11

Shaggy B,

Edinburgh 08/04/2008 14:23:05
#10, Andrew S: You are nothing but a racist. I would rather find myself living next to Mr Singh than to you.
12

Toast,

08/04/2008 14:24:39
#7 Very unlikely he had any insurance.
13

Arnie,

08/04/2008 14:49:21
These are dark days when the Govt. can steal your shares and local govt. can knock your property down.
14

c mains hibby,

edinburgh 08/04/2008 15:12:04
He has to look on the bright side, At least he wont have to worry about the neds burning it out again .
15

Mr H 2u,

Embra 08/04/2008 15:34:45
Hmm, I wonder if the parclife people had a wee word with one of their cooncil cronies?
16

Gastric Antral Vascular Ectasia,

08/04/2008 15:35:20
AndrewS, are you naturally such an awful human being, or do you have to take special pills?
17

Rigsby,

Edinburgh 08/04/2008 15:39:43
#16 and #11

Don't rise to AndrewS's trolling - just report unsuitable and he'll get deleted - I mean his post will get deleted...
18

fresian,

edinburgh 08/04/2008 15:52:48
Andrew 10, he probably has a better grasp of the English language than any of his customers.
19

Billy Effluvia,

France, Paris 08/04/2008 16:25:00
That's what I hated about working at a corner shop, the sheer drudgery of it. Drive into down, find somewhere to park, lock up, brave the rain and stop someone from knocking the place down.
20

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

08/04/2008 16:34:03
Andrew S, you can see above that Mr Singh does not say Ooga Booga olla walla , but instead he says english words.

21

,

08/04/2008 16:37:38
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
22

,

08/04/2008 16:53:41
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
23

,

08/04/2008 17:02:57
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
24

Graham P,

Edinburgh 08/04/2008 17:38:49
I imagine the compensation offer was before the fire - the clue is in the phrase "long been in negotiation". If the rest of the estate is being demolished and rebuilt, it stands to reason that the council would want to buy Mr Singh's shop and bulldoze it too.

Oh and Voldemort: I'm struggling to see what your xenophobic rant has to do with this story. Presumably you think if Mr Singh was white then the council would have treated him more harshly. By, er, knocking down his shop twice I suppose.
25

MishMoneypenny,

Edinburgh 08/04/2008 21:59:07
Lets just get this straight, right here and now. There is ABSOLUTELY NO WAY that Mr Sing would have been able to open that shop. The building was a ravaged shell of a building unsafe unstable and infested with vermin. I have documented the demolition and regeneration work with videos and photographs. The building was fecked. There are no houses in the area and the whole place is being demolished. Get a grip Mr Sing for feck sake.
26

fresian,

edinburgh 08/04/2008 22:07:57
MishMoneypenny, I think you'll find the vermin do their shopping at Lidl these days
27

Regen,

Edinburgh 08/04/2008 22:08:24
*25
I think you need to stop and think first, remember in the past it was set on fire. The insurance should have paid out but word was out, that the insurance didnt want to pay because of the area and the council didnt want to pay because the council wants the insurance to pay out. Mr Singh has told both parties to keep issues separate of interest. Seems like the council wanted to keep the money for themselves. Mr Singh should have been offered the first business opportunity being in the community for so long but wasn't, instead it was another shop owner across from him, who had an insider on the council to get not one but two businesses. A conspiracy I say....
28

tumshie heid,

08/04/2008 22:20:37
Jingsitsme. Just what exactly does "If it was you or I" mean?
Oh let me guess..more racist nonsense from you yet again.
29

Finbarr Saunders,

08/04/2008 23:56:44
This guy just comes across as a chancer, trying to get more money out of the Council than his shop is worth.

"Now any evidence that could have told us who started the fire has been destroyed."

Priceless!
30

Regen,

09/04/2008 00:43:39
*29

Are you daft? How can demolishing a shop gain more money? It's a loss you idiot. Some of the comments are priceless and uneducated lol! Finbarr lets burn your house lol! Anyway it's time to go, i finally finished reading my daily bulk of papers.
31

A. Greenman,

Edinburgh 09/04/2008 04:55:40
Mr. Singh should not be subjected to many of the personalised comments that I have read in the comments section.

As the owner of his property and therefore its maintainance, he should have been given an opportunity to make the building safe, with his own resources, before any demolition work was carried out.

None of us know what the terms of any discussions with City of Edinburgh Council were, so it is impossible to say whether the deal put forward by the Council to Mr. Singh, included an opportunity to take part in the so called Regeneration Plan that was supposed to have benefited the locals.

The whole point of refusing to budge when a Regeneration scheme is on the way, is to benefit from increased opportunities to Trade.

Looking at the spate of fires that have taken place in Craigmillar over the last decade or so at strategic points, & times of the rolling demolition plans, I for one am suprised the Free Press is not looking into the evidence more closely?

Mr. Singh's shop may have burnt down at a convinent time for people keen to realise its true value for themselves, shareholders or just because they can.

We should remember at a time like this, that men like Mr. Singh may be down for a short while, but need our support to get on the up again, because it could be one of us next time for whatever reason suits the powers that be.
32

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

09/04/2008 09:23:44
Well said 31.
33

A.A.,

Edinburgh 09/04/2008 09:29:46
18

You're probably spot on about that!
34

Jingsitsme,

EDINBURGH 09/04/2008 10:28:59
#31 - disagree totally. He just a chancer playing the system!!

It seems it always one section of society who are doing it and it nothing to do with being rasist or anything else.

Rules and regulations and the execution of them are for all not just some.

#29 you are on the right trail..
35

D Fiasco,

Walkerburn 09/04/2008 11:19:58
I smell a rat. A 'mysterious' fire destroys a restored building at the heart of a regenaration project. My heart goes out to Mr. Singh. He does appear to be the victim of very dirty politics.

As for you Andrew S. - I'm sure your inbred clan has very little to offer society compared to Mr. Singh's hardworking family. No doubt you're defrauding us all of tax funds as we speak to wallow in your mire of hatred and ignorance. Don't worry - you'll get yours someday; Karma's good that way.
36

Regen,

09/04/2008 15:53:12
I agree with 31 and definatley 35. Inbred, its a classic word to describe there type!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.