Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Wednesday, 9th December 2009

Bond writer 'framed the last witch in Britain'

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 14 May 2007
A HOUSEWIFE from Dundee who became the last woman to be jailed in Britain for witchcraft was framed by a team of British intelligence officers who worked with or for James Bond creator Ian Fleming, according to new research.
Robert Hartley claims fresh research into the trial documents - released to the National Archive - points to a state conspiracy to crack down on security leaks ahead of D-Day.

The academic and award-winning film-maker says that Helen Duncan, the
woman hailed as "Britain's last witch", was convicted in 1944 at the Old Bailey as an example to others.

Throughout the 1930s and 1940s Duncan, a mother of six, was a celebrated medium performing seances for the wives and widows left at home during the war.

Her technique was to go into a trance and produce ectoplasm through her mouth and nose which would form human shape and speak.

However, on 19 January, 1944, during a sitting in Portsmouth, Duncan conjured up a sailor from HMS Barham to talk to his surprised mother - who didn't know he was dead. The sinking of HMS Barham had been kept a secret by the navy for three months for operational reasons.

Fears that Duncan could be a spy led to an investigation by MI5 and Naval Intelligence who were alarmed by her access to secret information.

Only months before D-Day, Duncan was arrested and put on trial at the Old Bailey accused of contravening the Witchcraft Act of 1735.

"The authorities were terrified about potential security leaks and Duncan was in danger of disclosing military secrets during her seances," said Dr Hartley.

"Helen Duncan was giving out very accurate information. There were other mediums round the country giving out news on soldiers that had died and someone in authority took it seriously, whatever the source of the information."

After examining all the available documents for a new book on the conspiracy, Helen Duncan: The Mystery Show Trial, Dr Hartley suggests that among those responsible for the conspiracy to convict Duncan was James Bond author Ian Fleming, who was a key figure in the intelligence services at the time.

"I am convinced Naval Intelligence were working with MI5 and when I began looking at that connection, Ian Fleming's name kept cropping up as being involved with people either involved in the case or on the sidelines," said Dr Hartley.

On the basis of the evidence, much of which Dr Hartley claims appears to have been fabricated or at least exaggerated, Duncan was convicted and jailed.

More than half a century later, her case continues to be a cause célèbre with more than 30,000 websites, translated into several languages, detailing her story.

The official Helen Duncan website claims to have received at least 42 million visitors in the last few years, leading to a worldwide campaign for justice and a petition to the British government calling for the dowdy, plump housewife, who died in 1956, to be pardoned.

"We want to clear her name," said Michael Colmer, campaign co-ordinator and founder of the British Society of Paranormal Studies.

"There is no doubt that she was framed by the admiralty and our campaign has uncovered evidence that it was a conspiracy."

Duncan's supporters are now confident they can put right the original verdict and have petitioned the government for a full pardon.

Graham Hewitt, legal adviser to the campaign, is on the verge of completing a submission to the Home Office with evidence that Duncan was the subject of an admiralty conspiracy.



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 15 May 2007 1:07 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Witchcraft , James Bond
 
1

Scullion,

Canada 14/05/2007 01:18:01

Where did she get the information from?

2

Aoda,

Pennsylvania, USA 14/05/2007 02:45:50

Funny how all of a sudden that new documents are being discovered. All of it in the negative. Yep, the historians are out to discredit everyone that one learns, or reads about.

3

Marco,

14/05/2007 04:47:09

#3 Historians?

4

lisa,

perth 14/05/2007 05:36:17

Ian Fleming's mysogyny is apparent in all his books. He probably got a real kick out of framing Helen Duncan.

And how apt that they should pick Connery to play the first Bond. Uncanny.

5

wayne bijlyeerheid,

14/05/2007 05:57:47

#5
Was she one of "Big Tam's" milk round customers then?

Everybody else in Embra at that time was, apparently.

6

,

14/05/2007 06:53:45
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 619624, Article id was mapped to record!
7

,

14/05/2007 07:00:52
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 619637, Article id was mapped to record!
8

Boy Wonder,

14/05/2007 08:12:12

Apparently Helen Duncan lived for a time in a housing estate in Edinburgh. Which one?? Craigmillar. The old lag will have learned a few tricks in that place I suspect!!!

9

Firozali A.Mulla MBA PhD,

Dar-Es-Salaam Tanzania 14/05/2007 09:17:00

A HOUSEWIFE from Dundee who became the last woman to be jailed in Britain for witchcraft was framed by a team of British intelligence officers who worked with or for James Bond creator Ian Fleming, according to new research.

I read Macbeath and I did not see this one. There were three this one must have gone on holiday Say FBI CI ScotlandYard,Metropolitan,KKK , GODFATHER. KGB good they found the withch wich which voddoo > Thank you we managed to make the spider man III in time. The frogs they boils are alive. Spiderman would have eaten these.
Stupid story

10

,

14/05/2007 09:18:00
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 620013, Article id was mapped to record!
11

The west awake,

Argyll 14/05/2007 09:22:40

Sounds like she would be quite at home in Scottish Labour right now.
Another for the Chinese takeaway?

12

Ms Horrible Cankers,

The Cyber Shebeen 14/05/2007 09:44:25

1944!.....gawdstrewth that's embarrasing that...wonder if they checked her over for signs o' the deil?...

"Sgt! Sgt!..get a look at this!"

"What is it Dibble?...here gies a look"...staggers back in shock clutching his throat..

"A pair of black Marks n' Sparks control panel pants"..oh aye there's nae doubt about it now lads...clear the room and dont let this siren o' satan lay a fingir oan ye's boays or yer a gonner!"

13

AJ fae Fife,

Fife 14/05/2007 09:47:37

Re Last witch in Britain,

Lucky yer oot the country Canky...that's you oot the equation!!!!

14

Dave From Barra,

Western Isles 14/05/2007 09:51:13

Touche AJ for yesterdays shiny bonce debacle fae HC!

15

AJ fae Fife,

Fife 14/05/2007 09:57:05

Dave,

With a bit of luck she won't come back to this story and I can claim a victory!!!:))

16

Ms Horrible Cankers,

The Cyber Shebeen 14/05/2007 10:05:21

Pinch of gusset dust
and widows sorrow
fall on the head of AJ
So that he waketh up...ginger the morrow...

heh heh heh heh heh heh heh heh he he he he..

Your gaunny end up lookin like wan o' they Jimmy hats Fifer......

17

AJ fae Fife,

Fife 14/05/2007 10:15:54

Whit's "widows sorrow"?

Naw.....please.....naw ginger...anything...a'll dae anything!!!

18

Ms Horrible Cankers,

The Cyber Shebeen 14/05/2007 10:32:05

There is a witch buried somewhere in Scotland is there no...Alex Harvey sang about her...cannot remember for the life of me who she was...Isobel Goudie?...anybody know of her?...

Widow's sorrow?.....same thing as widowers I expect AJ....

Right if ye want this spell liftit ye hiv tae email the Mars company an demand that they remove animal rennet fae thir bars, bountys, minstrels and snickers (bliddy stupid name whit wis wrang wae marathon?) or yer gonny appear at thir headquarters covered in rid herr fae heid tae toe......

Best buy a large comb banjo boay....

19

AJ fae Fife,

Fife 14/05/2007 10:38:34

What aboot the chicken fat in MacDonald's milkshakes? D'ye want me tae pressurise them as weell!!??

btw, the East Neuk o' Fife was a hot bed of anti-witchy activity in the 17th and early 18th century! So be warned if ye ever come back tae here!!! We have long memories!!!!

20

Ms Horrible Cankers,

The Cyber Shebeen 14/05/2007 10:57:11

Naw...ah hate McD's..you jist stick tae the chocolate assignment and git oan the case...yer wastin time comin oan here tryin tae be a wideo...I ah suppose ahd stick oot like a sore thumb...no bein cross eyed..club fittit n' carryin a banjo eh?....every minute loast is another follicle filled so think on sunshine.....think on....kin ye no feel a wee ticklin sensation yit?....by the way...you still moonin ower mah cousin..the wan ye met in the bus stoap back in...whit wis it...83...noo eh?

Any takers oan Isobel Goudie yit?

21

AJ fae Fife,

Fife 14/05/2007 11:04:07
22

Audio,

Embra 14/05/2007 11:41:27

Ms Horrible Cankers - the witch that Alex sang about was indeed Isobel Goudie - I think she was from Alness or there abouts

23

Ms Horrible Cankers,

The Cyber Shebeen 14/05/2007 11:52:01

Pretty good AJ...would like to hear the original tho'...is there no supposed to be a horseshoe marks the spot of Isobel's grave or is that a myth?

24

AJ fae Fife,

Fife 14/05/2007 12:04:37

Why am a daein' aw the donkey work!!? Yer perfectly capable o' googlin' yersel!!!

Have ye googled yersel recently?!!!:)))

25

Ms Horrible Cankers,

The Cyber Shebeen 14/05/2007 12:13:28

Should yoo no be gaun fir yer lunch n' no hingin ower the keyboard aw day?...aside fae emailin mars that is?...aye very funny banjo boay...ye nivver answered ma question aboot ma cousin...Danny the tranny....the wan ye met in a bus shelter in 83...whaes tattoo you wir very admiring of....noo git emailing you HeeeHaaaw!

I'm away tae dae sum gerdnin...git away fae aw this madness...by the way...whit dis it mean when the screen turns bright yella n' stays that way an ye hiv tae switch the computer aff n' switch it back oan again?....

Noo...horseshoe..truth or legend?

26

AJ fae Fife,

Fife 14/05/2007 12:23:39

Couldnae huv been me, ma goth in the bus shelter didnae huv ony undercarriage hinging!!! And you would huv sworn a'd been eating a fish supper efter!!!!

Horse shoe is true!!!

27

Neil,

9% Growth 14/05/2007 14:09:28

Well she was either getting information from the spirits or from gossip. My suspicion is the latter.

Careless talk did cost lives in those days so it was quite proper that she be banged up.

28

Joanna,

Cambs, England 14/05/2007 15:03:18

"Her technique was to go into a trance and produce ectoplasm through her mouth and nose which would form human shape and speak"


This sounds revolting - the woman obviously had a bad cold or a way with getting phlegm out of her body which was second to none.

If any of my long-dead relatives turned themselves into snot and started chatting to me..... I think it would be time to get myself admitted to the nearest loony bin!!

29

Cadgers,

Perth 14/05/2007 15:21:38

#31 Cankers, Dunning has their own monument dunno if it's the one you were thing of.
http://www.photo.zeugma.co.uk/scotland/witch-burnings-sco...

30

Peajay,

Herts, England 14/05/2007 15:36:06

Joanna,
Thanks for that down to gutter level description. You just couldn't resist could you? :)

31

Joanna,

Cambs, England 14/05/2007 15:41:34

Sorry Peajay

But, the woman must have got through some Kleenex!! :D

32

Peajay,

Herts, England 14/05/2007 15:43:27

No, she came from Dundee, she'd have just used her sleeve!! :)

33

Geoff W,

Upyonder 14/05/2007 16:42:41

The Barham sank 25th November 1941.

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=7009975008653689943

Relatives were immediately asked to remain silent on their loss.

"Three months later" would be 19 Jan 1942 and not 1944 as stated.

Berlin radio (Lord Haw Haw?) broadcast the news on the 12th January 1942 reproduced in some minor US newspapers on 13th January - see Google news archive.

So on 19th January Helen Duncan was just relaying Lord Haw Haw's message surely.

The Admiralty lifted the press embargo on the news on 27th January 1942.

I've never heard the 19th January mentioned in this context before but by all means nail this story with the facts and accurate dates.

34

Ms Horrible Cankers,

The Cyber Shebeen 14/05/2007 16:51:07

32...Aye well 'e wis a bit hermaphrodiphic the poor soul so ye widnae hae know AJ..an hygiene wis an issue fir im cos 'e wis oan the game anaw like...bus stoap wis 'es knockin shoap know whit ah mean?...hid quite a few punters awready that day...anyroad 'e sais yoo hiv tae refine yer tekneek...said ye hid aw the finesse o' a dug wae a bone....oh aye an ye owe 'im a tenner....

31...Cadgers thanks for that..different wumman but I'd heard aboot that as well...no quite oan par wae the Jeanne D'Arc monument here....but then again she wis jist that bit merr famous eh?

35

Douglas,

Bathgate 14/05/2007 17:45:07

Joanna #37: A tissue of lies. It was only the bogey man.:o)

36

Ms Horrible Cankers,

The Cyber Shebeen 14/05/2007 18:17:36

Or 'Hairy Snotter'...teenage witch extraordinaire!

37

Ms Horrible Cankers,

The Cyber Shebeen 14/05/2007 22:40:01

43....Aye well if its mah blood they want they cannae hiv it...mah bidey in'sa forriner...nice fella mah Shuggee...bit 'es French so ye kin nivver tell whaur 'es bin know whit ah mean?..cannae be giein blood me...noo AJ...the boay's obviously feelin 'es goat a wee bit too much'n 'es lookin tae part wae some...thats the way ah see it like...'es goat some cheek so 'e his....nipped ma cousin Danny the tranny back in 83 an tried tae kid oan it wis me?...ahm fair affrontit...thon Danny's goat a set o' gnashers oan 'im like Red Rum....an 'es honkin...jist goes tae show ye....'e must hae bin a bit desparate eh?.....

Ginger nut biscuits?...ginger nuts merr like...oho Mrs AJ wid be in fir a treat eh?...heh heh heh heh..

38

AJ fae Fife,

Fife 14/05/2007 22:55:20

weeshooie1,

Fan club!!!?? Whit a scary thought! As for the ginger spell, a think it's taking effect!! Had tae strim the ears the nicht, normally it's wance a month, but that wiz the second time today!!! Cankers is indeed a witch!!!!

Cankers,

Lickily, the pubes are still non-existant!!! Still think it wiz you Canky, back in '83, a ended up wi crabs in ma eyebrows, ya minger!!!

39

Ms Horrible Cankers,

The Cyber Shebeen 14/05/2007 23:10:02

Noo come oan AJ ye ken fine well thats cos ye curl up in a baw whin ye go tae sleep...you been a wee fella an aw that...use it is a pilla eh?....ah mean...whit dae ye expect whin yer stalkin trannies..thinkin ye kin hide unnerneath thir skirts an they'l no notice ye?.....

40

AJ fae Fife,

Fife 14/05/2007 23:19:01

HC,

Yer an awfy wumin right enough!!! Am jist aboot done in, fair puggled so a am, time fur ma scratcher!!!

It's a full time joab takin' you oan and gettin' slaughtered every nicht, fairly taks it oot o' me!!!

41

Ms Horrible Cankers,

The Cyber Shebeen 14/05/2007 23:21:53

Aye bit whits a 'Pittenweem herber'?

Nite nite, sleep tite..dont lit the crabs bite!

42

AJ fae Fife,

Fife 14/05/2007 23:30:52

G'nite Canky

PS go easy the morn or it'll be the prozac fur me!!!

43

Geoff W,

Upyonder 15/05/2007 21:27:26

#39 Correction - the arrest date was 19 Jan 1944 but the seance at which the sailor materialized was supposedly late 1941. The Barham, one of Clydebank's finest, sank three years before she was arrested not three months. Both seances did take place in Portsmouth though.

The Scotsman added to the wartime pantomime by reporting that Sherlock Holmes had appeared to a JP at one of her seances.

As the heather-lowper herself would have said "I never hee'd so mony lies in a' my life".

It would be nice if the Scotsman made public their wartime accounts of both HMS Barham and the trial and revealed their messages from the Admiralty.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.