Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Thursday, 26th November 2009

Four of Scotland's buildings in line for top award

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 09 June 2008
SOME of Scotland's most high-profile building projects, including the refurbishment of Kelvingrove Museum and the regeneration of the former Edinburgh Royal Infirmary site, have been shortlisted for a top award.
Four Scottish projects are among the 54 schemes nominated for the annual Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (Rics) awards.

The A-listed Kelvingrove Art Gallery and Museum in Glasgow is up for best conservation project, while the £450 millio
n Quartermile project to transform a 19-acre hospital site in the capital has been nominated for best regeneration scheme.

Eden Court Theatre and Cinema in Inverness has been shortlisted in the best community benefit category, while a forestry commission office in the Highland city has been nominated for most sustainable building for its use of timber from the surrounding area.

St Pancras Station and the 02 Arena in London are among the favourites for the overall Rics prize, which is announced in October.

Scottish architecture experts were last night divided on the nominations. Adrian Welch, an architect who worked on the Scottish Parliament and is the editor of two leading Scottish architecture websites, said: "Four out of 54 is a bit disappointing, but it does fit with a bit of a lull in Scotland where we are still producing good-quality building projects, but not at the same rate as a few years ago.

"They are all good projects, but I am surprised to not see something as strong as the Pier Arts Centre in Orkney included."

But Sebastian Tombs, chief executive of Scotland's design watchdog Architecture and Design Scotland, said: "These are all quality projects and a good indicator of the diversity on offer in Scotland.

"The Forestry Commission building is a good example of the use of Scottish building materials while Quartermile has really taken on the challenges of redeveloping the World Heritage site."

Simon Pott, the chairman of the Rics judging panel, said: "The response has been excellent this year."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 09 June 2008 12:17 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Architecture
 
1

Statsman,

Edinburgh 09/06/2008 03:08:39
Quartermile? You're having a laugh!
2

Tamus,

High Street 09/06/2008 09:18:21
#1

Couldn't agree more. That project has destroyed the Edinburgh skyline. How did it get Planning Permission "it helps if you have Sir Norman Foster on your side" City of Edin Planning Dept.
3

DAVID,

Edinburgh 09/06/2008 09:48:16
I think I am going to go into the architecture business.

I'm sure I could design something like Quartermile pretty easily - all you have do is knock down most of what was there and chuck in some glass boxes around the edges plus some big square and rectangular container type things on the roofs.

Hey presto - one "award winning" set of modern buildings.
4

Jockdogma,

UK 09/06/2008 10:14:19
Q-mile is a great scheme underatken on a technically challenging site. It has regenerated a derelict site and has retained a large number of the existing structures in order to provide a balance between old and new and has created some excellent public relam. I agree that some scheme can be pretty poor (this isn't one of them)but I can't believe that we are suggesting our planning laws are relaxed, it's an absolute nightmare to get anything through in Edinburgh. Q-Mile is an excellent example of progressive development
5

DAVID,

Edinburgh 09/06/2008 10:18:49
#4 - what about the container type boxes on the roofs of Quartermile that spoil the skyline. Do you really think these are great to look at?

Dull, dull, dull. Not creative, not exciting, not harmonious, not sympathetic. Computer generated, template architecture.
6

Seb,

09/06/2008 10:34:08
"computer generated"? I think Lego played a more important part in the design process. Glassy vacuous architecture.
7

A Clamper,

Edinburgh 09/06/2008 10:46:59
Quartermile is nowhere near the finished article, but once it is and the new public square is constructed and the shops cafes and bars are open, as well as a new hotel together with the refurbishment and conversion to flats of many of the original buildings
and the building of new affordable homes as well then I think people will appreciate the regeneration of the area.
8

Annoyingboi,

Edinburgh 09/06/2008 13:52:02
Q-Mile is yet another nail in Edinburgh's world heritage!
9

malmeg,

Boca Raton 09/06/2008 17:42:46
I studied architecture at Edinburgh U. many years ago and worked for the preeminent architectural firm RAKP in Rutland Square before emigrating to the US. On a recent trip to Edinburgh I was appalled at the awful architecture of the 90's and today. The Scottish Parliament Building and the building I think called Scottish Heritage Museum or something like that, are extremely poor examples of Scottish architecture. Where are the Kininmonths and Spences of yesteryear?
10

malmeg,

Boca Raton 09/06/2008 17:54:51
Sorry for that mis-naming in my previous comment #9. The name of that most awful building is the Museum of Scotland, not Scottish Heritage museum.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.