Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Wednesday, 9th December 2009

2,000 nuts that hold up Forth road bridge must be replaced

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 16 April 2009
FORTH Road Bridge officials have confirmed they will have to replace nearly 2,000 heavy duty nuts that help to hold up the structure, after The Scotsman revealed last year the repair was on the cards.
The problem, thought to be a world first on a suspension bridge, will take several years to rectify, but traffic will not be disrupted during remedial work.

More than £600,000 is expected to be spent on the new nuts after cracks were found in nine of the 1,888 that help secure 192 vertical steel-rope "hangers" connecting the bridge's main suspension cables to the vehicle carriageways. The bolts they are attached to may also have to be replaced.

The Forth Estuary Transport Authority (Feta), which runs the bridge, said the replacement work was precautionary and the structure remained safe.

The nuts secure cable bands to the suspension cables – cable bands are metal castings over which the hangers holding up the roadway are looped. Each cable band is held in place by a number of 35mm diameter steel bolts, pre-tensioned to a load of about 80 tonnes.

All the cable-band nuts and bolts were replaced ten years ago, but an inspection last year found the cracked nuts. They had been expected to last 30 years.

Feta then ordered an investigation, which found design and specification decisions and construction methods that may have contributed to the cracking.

The investigation found misalignment of washers may have led to uneven loading in the nuts, and the protective coating on the nuts may have allowed moisture to cause the damage.

Feta is seeking legal advice to find out whether the designer, or the contractor who replaced the nuts in the 1990s, is liable and can be sued for compensation.

Four of the failed nuts have been replaced on the west cable, using access platforms already in place. The five failed nuts on the east cable will be replaced this year.

Barry Colford, the bridgemaster and chief engineer, said: "Thanks to the vigilance of our inspection team, this problem was identified at an early stage and the bridge remains perfectly safe.

"Cracks have been found in only nine out of 1,888 similar nuts. Nevertheless, our investigation has concluded that any of these nuts could potentially fail in future, so the recommendation is to replace them all as a precaution. We're planning further tests in the laboratory before bringing a final report to the Feta board later this year."

Neil Greig, the Scotland director of the Institute of Advanced Motorists' Motoring Trust, said: "It is reassuring to hear the bridge is perfectly safe, but it is always worrying for drivers to hear of yet another new problem. The good news is that this problem has been caught early and can be addressed without causing extra congestion.

"In the long term, we remain most concerned about rust and other deep-seated cable issues."


Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 16 April 2009 12:21 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Forth Bridges
 
1

Padraig,

16/04/2009 00:17:07
Sounds like routine maintenance to me.

Nothing to see here! Keep the traffic moving along!
2

AJM,

16/04/2009 00:24:42
2000 nuts to be replaced, with what more nuts! There are too many nuts loose these days.
3

,

16/04/2009 00:33:25
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
4

Alec M,

Falkirk 16/04/2009 00:34:04
Just hope they don't pay in peanuts for the work.
5

Fred Leeson,

edinburgh 16/04/2009 00:36:37
Heck their arms must be aching. I'm not surprised that they're being replaced.
6

truthsleuth,

16/04/2009 01:02:19
Amongst the supporters of the White elephant of a second Forth Road bridge they should find enough nuts to replace the 20,00 cracked nuts on the first bridge. Any shortage could be made up from AS SMPs
7

eamon,

16/04/2009 01:11:06
there were a few nuts having dinner just under the bridge tonight that also need replacing.
8

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 16/04/2009 01:18:10
This, of course, is the Forth road bridge at North and South Queensferry and should not be mistaken for the one at Stirling, nor the 2 which traverse the Forth from Stirlingshire northward to Fife.
9

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 16/04/2009 01:22:57

I agree with Padraig @#,

Another "routine maintenance" a bit like the,'paint job', just finished, just to have to start all over again.

eamon @#7,

"there were a few nuts having dinner just under the bridge tonight that also need replacing"

You made me Laugh!, it is getting to the 'Tourist Time' right enough!

I would be more worried about the 'wing nuts' and their droppings, the 'Bird Flu' is coming soon!

10

Robert Wiener,

Naples 16/04/2009 02:58:28
The failure of nuts and the earlier failure of cables show that the new Firth crossing should be a tunnel which would require much less maintenance than either the existing bridge or a new one. Is it too late to make a change?
11

JulesF,

Kirkliston 16/04/2009 04:48:07
It's well known that Feta are a bunch of nuts and need replaced so why is this news ?
12

Mercutio,

FALKIRK 16/04/2009 05:55:31
#11 This is obviously a cheesey story!
13

Albawolf,

St Andrews 16/04/2009 07:49:03
The A9 was spec'd as Dual ALL the way

Yet the Glasgow Party cut it back
(the motorways to NOWWHERE in Glasgow remained UNCUT)

Why should this jump the queue..........

Put the Tolls back and reduce the traffic

But spend the money fairly acrosss ALL the country........

Ignore the queue jumpers.................

But they will NOT...........


14

drunken proffet,

Tassy 16/04/2009 08:12:51
The Forth Road Bridge is not the kind of thing you could sell on the world market. However see the Glasgow underground and the idea to re-develop it. If you have a load of passenger carriages in a warehouse doing nothing and conforming to a thirty six inch by three and three eights gauge, it would help if one or two were designed my Charles Mackintosh, but not really essential. I reckon the Tasmanian Railway Societies would take them off your hands. Just to free up expensive warehouse space. Mind you if you do sell them you will have to come to Tasmania to enjoy the experience.
15

Jacqueline Hyde ,

On the shelf 16/04/2009 08:38:47
Thank goodness the Scotsman discovered the problem in time. The good folk in Edinburgh can still sleep easy at night in the knowledge that their escape route to far better places hasn't been cut off.
16

Tartan Viking,

16/04/2009 10:02:46
How about replacing the nuts at Westminster?
17

Mcsnagpile,

16/04/2009 10:03:01
Independent Client supervision and direct end of work responsibility for every stage of the project is required.

Where is the Quality control and Accountability by signature?
If there are any signatures? can we publish them on rogue’s gallery?

I recently heard senior management, on another project calling, QC inspectors NAZI’s.
18

El Franko,

16/04/2009 11:07:45
I would like to express my appreciation to all those nuts, for their many years of service.
19

Strict Ivan Jellicoe,

Renfrew 16/04/2009 12:25:35
Will replacing these nuts turn into a Forth Bridge job?

On the plus side, the civil engineers managing the progect had also project managed the Scottish Parliament building
20

,

16/04/2009 12:33:38
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
21

bluehead,

edinburgh 16/04/2009 13:02:26
I thought all the nuts were in the house of commons
that's the only conclusion one can come to after listening to that pile!!!!!
22

For Scotlands Future,

Vote For The SNP 16/04/2009 15:13:12
Just hope that they don't try and loosen them off all at the same time.

How many cans of WD40 will this take??
23

Richard Lionheart,

16/04/2009 16:11:14
Thought this was another story about Environmentalists!
24

Brianwci,

16/04/2009 19:07:40
#1 Padraig. I'm with you too Padraig, normal maintenance, what's the big deal? Trouble is so many of us are affected by the constant flow of press negativity and hype.

But as sales are more important than the mental and emotional health of the populace we will probably have to put up with it for some time to come.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Would you support the return of tolls to fund a new Forth Road Bridge?
No, it should be paid for in the same way as other roads.
Yes, it’s fairer for users to bear the brunt of the cost.
Yes, as long as it was only for a fixed amount of time.


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.