Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Tuesday, 13th May 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Rare sea eagle 'killed three months after its release'



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
04 December 2007
A SEA eagle from Norway which was released on the east coast of Scotland is believed to have been deliberately killed on a grouse moor, police said yesterday.
Wildlife crime officers said an informant had told them the white-tailed sea eagle - one of 15 set free in Fife in August as part of a reintroduction programme - had been killed on an estate in Angus. The informant had also named the person responsib
le.

The eagle's body had not been found, but a tracking device fitted to the bird had stopped giving out a signal, suggesting it had been disabled.

The last native sea eagle was shot in 1918. A reintroduction programme began in the 1970s on the west coast, where there are now 42 breeding pairs.

Alan Stewart, Tayside Police's wildlife and environment officer, said:

"It is really scandalous. Here we are trying to reintroduce birds that have been killed off 100 years ago and the allegation is one has been killed already, just a few months into the release programme."

He added: "Most shooting estates give us no cause for concern, but the particular estate named by the informant has been at the centre of concerns over illegal practices in the past few years."

The 12 remaining Norwegian birds - two were killed on power lines - are now spread from St Fergus in Aberdeenshire to Loch Leven and Perthshire.

Alex Hogg, the chairman of the Scottish Gamekeepers Association,

doubted gamekeepers were involved, as eagles caused no problem on grouse moors.

But he added: "I thought this would lead to trouble. As soon as one of these birds is found dead, the finger gets pointed at a shooting estate."

Michael Russell, Scotland's environment minister, said that he was "deeply disturbed to hear reports that one of these magnificent birds has come to deliberate harm".

Stuart Housden, the director of RSPB Scotland, said: "We are shocked and saddened that the gift of sea eagles from the people of Norway to Scotland should be blighted by what appears to be a deliberate act of illegal persecution by this selfish estate."

• THE Scotsman is committed to helping the Scottish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals catch those responsible for killing birds of prey and other wildlife. Information about wildlife crimes can be passed to police via the National Wildlife Crime Unit in North Berwick on 01620 893607.



The full article contains 404 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 03 December 2007 9:24 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Shooting & Fishing
 
1

Friar Tuck,

04/12/2007 02:17:13

Name the "alleged" estate.

2

COLINTON.MAINS,

canada 04/12/2007 02:42:03

you.are.not.helping.by.not.naiming.place

3

Faye,

04/12/2007 02:49:41

The Estate should be named so that everyone, both locally and nationally, are aware of the culprits.

What happened to Sandman? #47

http://news.scotsman.com/index.cfm?id=1583732007 #47 removed and #53.

He allegedly found a black bin bag floating down the River Esk, with 20 buzzards, a golden eagle and a peregrine falcon.

He said nothing was done when he reported the crime to the police and said the bag was found down stream from a nearby estate http://www.flyfish-scotland.com/rsouthesk.htm

Seen the Media photo shoots with politicians claiming they will do more to catch the culprits.

Can their words be turned into action?

4

W Smith,

Middle East 04/12/2007 03:27:29

I would suggest Alan Stewart , the kiddy-on policeman, does something about the thugs in Dundee instead of wasting time getting all emotional over this.

He can declare a gamekeeper 'amnesty' where the gamekeepers can hand in their poison and shotguns.

We all know what a succes the knife 'amnesty' was in Glasgow eh Mr Stewart?

5

,

04/12/2007 06:37:59
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
6

Boy Wonder,

04/12/2007 08:08:56

Name the vile perpetrator! Then jail them!!!

7

Dave from Barra ©,

Western Isles 04/12/2007 08:17:11

W Smith

Alan Stewart specialises in Wildlife crime, it is his charge. The man has worked through the ranks and wildlife crime prevention is a signature of a civilised society.

excolinton.mains

Need need to put a full stop between words, try using the space bar if you have one. Assuming you are using a standard qwerty keyboard, it's the biggest key at the bottom of the board.

Really, there is no need for killing these birds. However, I note that 2 have been killed in over head power lines. That is good evidence NOT to build the super pylons from Denny to Buely nor riddle our countryside wind wind turbines.

8

Jock MacTamson,

Highlands 04/12/2007 09:32:05

Lets not be kidding ourselves.

These estates are owned and run as businesses. The express instructions given to the game keepers is kill all threats to revenue. I know many game keepers and they are doing a job while living in employment conditions of the 1800's. Their wages are very low so that most make this up with tips.

They can lose their job, their home and their reputation in the closenit Hooray Henry Brigade overnight if they even considered not protecting the stocks of game birds.

What I am implying is that the majority of Estate in Scotlands Highlands poison and kill what ever suits them.

9

GP,

04/12/2007 09:36:10

NO evidence.
trial by hearsay what is this coiuntry coming to?

10

sam the god,

04/12/2007 10:02:11

BELIEVED to have been deliberately killed.
The eagle's BODY had not been FOUND.
What APPEARS to be a deliberate act of illegal persecution by this selfish estate.

These statements are speculative and may not actually be factual.

The informant had also named the person responsible (have the police checked whether the informant is into animal rights and could have an ulterior agenda?)

The 12 remaining Norwegian birds - two were killed on power lines could this missing one also have died as a result of power lines?

Could the sea eagle have been killed by other raptors and the tracking device been damaged as a result?

11

TBM,

Glesga 04/12/2007 11:13:35

I blame Chon

12

Devils Advocate,

Midlothian 04/12/2007 12:07:37

Any significance to the fact that this estate is in an area where 4 wind farms have been applied for?
Remember the Golden Eagle a few months ago poisoned on an estate near Peebles next to an area where 2 wind farms have been applied for?
Coincidence?
I dont think so.

13

ignorant townie?,

Scotland 04/12/2007 12:44:09

If the police had all the facts there would have been a prosecution to follow..

but they obviously dont..so ask yourselves why this story has appeared?

the police must have very very good evidence about what occurred or they would not have put this story out - for a start, this produces just such a negative reaction from the "persecution deniers" as we see in this Forum...

the police in that part of the world have been bending over backwards to accomodate the estates and gamekeepers...there has obviously been a major setback to that plan...

Oh yes..and Pie and a Pint [7 or 8 pints by the sound of it]...where did you hear that the witness in the Sandringham case was "unreliable"??...have you any idea what that young man was risking by reporting what he saw, on a Royal Estate?!...catch a grip....

14

ignorant townie?,

Scotland 04/12/2007 12:51:06

"Alex Hogg, the chairman of the Scottish Gamekeepers Association,

doubted gamekeepers were involved, as eagles caused no problem on grouse moors. "

Does Mr Hogg think we actually believe this nonsense??...golden eagles still get shot on grouse moors [and you dont shoot one of them by mistake], there is a long history of eagle persecution by gamekeepers in Scotland...just ask any old grouse keeper [off the record of course]..

There are plenty of records of eagle killing on grouse moors in books written throughout the 19th and 20th centuries..

Eagles eat grouse as part of their diet if they live in grouse areas [what a surprise] ..they also scare the bejesus out of grouse when they fly over a moor...thats why keepers kill them..

Its most certainly not an excuse but its why they do it...

15

sam the god,

04/12/2007 13:08:36

A question that should also be asked are the sea eagles protected by any current legislation as they have been extinct in the UK for over 100 years and as such they are no longer an indigenous species but have been imported?

If there is no legislation to protect them then if they were shot no crime has been committed and the witness in theory should be charged with wasting police time.

16

WHISTLEBLOWER,

04/12/2007 17:39:03

"Name the "alleged" estate."

They can't until it's proven.

17

Corstorphinery,

Tentsmuir 04/12/2007 20:18:34

I saw one of the released birds the other week. It was idly pecking a dead pheasant (I run them over daily) at the side of the road. It flew off and had a wingspan the size of a large door.

It think the RSPB know that by releasing these birds on the east coast, they will be too tempting for the chinless twits in tweed and their neanderthal keepers to resist. Difficult to believe that a dozen or so raptors will have as big an effect on the grouse population than several hundred twelve bores. Mind you, you should see some of them shoot.....

18

bald eagle,

04/12/2007 22:07:13

A lot of the above comments are either keen to believe in the conspiracy theories or argue that without complete proof it is verging on slanderous to tarnish the good name of our guardians of the countryside!!

This bird had a tracker fitted, it'll have been tracked to the location of its demise; the report states the police have the name of the person responsible; the record of this estate has been outed as deplorable.

Face facts folks, it's been knobbled, but without the carcase the police are going to struggle to put together a case.

When the chairman of the SGA recently suggested that the evidence (dead eagles) is recycled by police for investigation all over the country it's obvious that he is getting desperate for excuses!!

19

Embaba,

Scotland 04/12/2007 23:16:21

Shameful, primative and disgusting.

People from this 'industry' have the key to stopping these practices.

Report wildlife criminals to the police.

Scotland deserves better.

Alex Hogg=King Canute

20

Conan,

Moffat 05/12/2007 00:20:27

Bird hunting should be banned in Scotland and the 'grouse moors' made into nature reserves - with NO compensation to their 'owners'.

21

An Australian of Scottish Ancestry,

05/12/2007 01:08:12

Any reprobate who would knowingly and deliberately kill a beautiful, protected bird deserves to be struck with the full weight of the book. On that note, I wonder what action would be taken against that overindulged parasite, Prince Harry, if it turned out that it was actually him who shot the Spatch harrier over the grounds of Buckingham Palace.

However, how can the likes of Conan (#25) seriously justify or asperse a ban on the legitimate and controlled hunting of grouse and other identified game species? The hunting of game birds is actually an essential component in the process of conservation, and necessary in preventing the overpopulation of species in the wild to ensure their overall, continued survival.

Oh Conan, if you question the ownership of the moors, many of which are upon lands that have been owned by various clans since the time of Robert I, and the right of the owners to own them, then why don't you sell your residence and give the money to a wildlife trust?

22

J J PETTIGREW,

05/12/2007 01:45:50

Unfortunately most of our countryside is owned by
the descendants of those that put the real owners to the sword, those interbred fitz nob heads who strut about blasting anything that moves, as for the Battenburgs, I use their correct surname here, Just like their father a waste of space!
These people( used in the loosest possible term) have scant regard for local communities ,never mind wildlife, just as their ancestors raised babies by their sabres , if john mclean had had his dream they would all be hung from the nearest lampost.

23

Conan,

Moffat 05/12/2007 23:04:49

OK, #26 - you have a deal. I'll give my farmhouse outside Moffat to the Wildlife Trust just as soon as all you trespassers in Oz hand the continent back to its righful owners, the Aborigines.

Deal or No Deal?


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.