Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 21st November 2009

Mary Queen of Scots to be a Scarlett woman in new movie

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 30 September 2006
THERE's something about Mary that Hollywood just can't keep away from.
Actress Scarlett Johansson has just been cast to depict the doomed Royal in a forthcoming movie being written by Jimmy McGovern, creator of TV's Cracker.

Expected to start filming next summer, the movie will focus on the relationship between the
young Mary Queen of Scots and her cousin, Elizabeth I, the monarch who eventually agreed to her execution at the age of 44 in 1587.

The role will see Johansson follow in the footsteps of a bevy of screen sirens who have played the Scottish queen, dating back at least 70 years to when Katherine Hepburn starred in Mary of Scotland, directed by John Ford.

It is the second recent foray into the world of Elizabethan history for McGovern, one of television's most accomplished writers. In 2004, he wrote a two-part mini-series Gunpowder, Treason and Plot, which examined the story not only of Mary but also her son James the Sixth of Scotland and First of England, who unified the two kingdoms in 1603.

Johansson - voted "sexiest woman alive" by FHM magazine - has shown a taste for period drama. She stars in a forthcoming film, The Other Boleyn Girl, which covers the little-known story of Mary Boleyn, mistress to King Henry VIII before he married her sister, Anne.

The film is being developed by American company 2929 Entertainment and is likely to begin shooting next summer.

While a major studio backer has yet to be announced, the involvement of a grade-A celebrity like Johansson means financial support is certain from Hollywood's moguls.

The budget for the movie is slated at a provisional £16 million and it is being produced by Melanie Johansson, the actress' mother and also her manager.

Described at the time as tall, graceful and quick-witted, Mary was married three times and her colourful private life has been the subject of endless historical speculation. The focus on Mary's early life means the 21-year-old Hollywood star is likely to put her smouldering allure to good use.

Stuart Kemp, the London bureau chief for Hollywood Reporter magazine, said: "They cast young people in these roles because they want them to be beautiful and glamorous.

"Obviously, Mary Queen of Scots, at some levels, is a sexy kind of story."

However, Kemp said he also believed Johansson's glacial looks would allow her to adopt a haughty royal air where necessary. "I think she will get as close to the role as you can," he said.

Edinburgh-based film critic Brian Pendreigh said: "Historically, Mary Queen of Scots was bright, she was tall, she was good looking. For her time she would have been very well-educated. Scarlett Johansson would fit that bill, she is a very modern sort of woman."

Queen of drama, always a challenge to the acting profession


SCARLETT Johansson follows in a long list of stars who have tried to capture the essence of the doomed royal on screen. Film critic Brian Pendreigh gives his verdict on some:

• Katherine Hepburn in Mary of Scotland (1936), directed by John Ford. The film starred Florence Eldridge as Elizabeth I. Ford's expertise in westerns made him an odd choice to oversee this film. "The casting of Katherine Hepburn wasn't a problem - everything else was about the film. It is a shortbread-tin version of Mary Queen of Scots."

• Vanessa Redgrave in the 1971 movie Mary, Queen of Scots. She played opposite Glenda Jackson, feted for her performance as an icy Virgin Queen. The film featured sumptuous costumes and scenery while taking licence with history. "Glenda Jackson probably overshadowed Vanessa Redgrave. Basically, it was a bit dull."

• Clémence Poésy, the Parisian actress, was Mary in the 2004 British TV mini- series Gunpowder, Treason and Plot. "She struck me as a very good Mary Queen of Scots and you also had a French actress in the role."

• Barbara Flynn played Mary Queen of Scots in the Channel Four series Elizabeth I (2005). The mini-series, starring Helen Mirren as Elizabeth I, wowed America and won nine Emmy awards.

• However, the first cinematic attempt to depict the short life of Mary was a one-minute American production made in 1895 called The Execution of Mary Stuart.

Depicting Mary's last moments, it was gruesomely to the point.



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 29 September 2006 8:16 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Mary Queen of Scots
 
1

Steve Evans,

Malta 30/09/2006 06:07:19

Always thought Nicole Kidman would make the perfect Mary Queen of Scots in any film.

2

Bell-the-Cat,

Hermitage 30/09/2006 06:30:45

Oh dear. Gunpowder, Treason and Plot was absolutely diabolical. Why on earth can't they tell the real story of MQS? It is profoundly dramatic. McGovern's screenplay was so bad it was funny. Psychotic James VI down in England for his mother's funeral?

Elizabeth and Mary NEVER met each other! I'll bet they do in this film.

3

Bell-the-Cat,

Hermitage 30/09/2006 06:31:36

sorry, 'funeral' should be 'execution'

4

AJ,

Fife 30/09/2006 08:06:08

Michelle McManus would be excellent in the role of the Queen!

5

Fannybawz,

amsterdam 30/09/2006 08:38:54

Don,t look up beheading on the net.In this world there are some very very sick people.

6

Ian G,

Edinburgh 30/09/2006 08:44:23

The true story is fascinating enough, tell it like it was.

Sadly she made some bad choices.
Unlucky to be around with religious conflict within Europe. John Knox was no help.
Mary was probably too nice. A fish out of water.
Yeah they will have them meet, film makers can't help themselves.

7

maggie,kitty,

edinburgh 30/09/2006 09:32:14

they will just make a mess off the whole story as they did with wallace.

8

Joanna,

Cambs 30/09/2006 09:36:39

The jury seems to be still out on Mary Queen of Scots. How involved was she in the murder of Darnley? Did she go willingly with Bothwell to Dunbar Castle or was she abducted and raped?

Yes, I agree - Nicole Kidman would make a good Mary - she has the right colouring for a start. Helena Bonham Carter would be good as Elizabeth or Cate Blanchett who has played her before.

Guaranteed that the film makers will get them to meet up ..... even though they never did in real life. A dramatic meeting between the two Queens is too much of a temptation for any director to pass up.

9

AJ,

Fife 30/09/2006 10:39:32

Ian,

John Knox met with Mary several times and there was a certain respect between them, apparently. He tried to find some common ground, but she was determind to stick to her faith no matter the politics.

She was just a continuation of the disasterous Stewart/Stuart dynasty. That's the trouble with Monarchy.

Joanna, there is no doubt Bothwell was a badyin, but the romantics got a hold of the story a long time ago and have blurred the detail. It would seem Mary was put upon, but I think she just couldn't adapt to Scotland - especially with her rearing in the French Court. Coupled with the idea of devine right, she was doomed from the start in the turbulent Scottish Court!

I still think Michelle McManus is the one, with Julian Clary playing Queen Elizabeth

10

Steve Evans,

Malta 30/09/2006 10:45:04

I've always thought that grave in the Canongate Kirk,Edinburgh reputed to be Rizzos could lead to some interesting answers, especially as the Stuarts ended up in Italy? A project like the recent De Medici investigation led to some interesting results, imagine the Rizzo murder, interesting???

11

Joanna,

Cambs 30/09/2006 11:28:50

There was an old rumour that James VI was actually Rizzo's child and that is why Rizzo was murdered. There is also an old story about the real prince dying as a baby and being buried in the walls of Holyrood and a changeling being brought up as James VI. Fascinating stuff and it certainly seems to prove the case that conspiracy theories are not a modern invention.

Julian Clary as Elizabeth - well, he would certainly camp up the role of the old dominatrix!!;))

12

AJ,

Fife 30/09/2006 11:44:23

Joanna,

I think it could work. Julian is renowned for his bouts of celibacy, so he could ease into the virgin role!

13

inter alia,

Edinburgh 30/09/2006 11:44:51

[11: Joanna] What a wonderful idea. How'd you know EI liked the old s&m ?

14

Steve Evans,

Malta 30/09/2006 12:22:24

Joanna, The portraits of JameaVI and David Rizzio do seem very much alike. I wonder if after the death of James and internment in Henry VIIths Tudor vault in Westminster Abbey, he was even embarrassed to face his mother and cousin Arbella in the Stuart vault, even in death.

15

Joanna,

Cambs 30/09/2006 12:37:48

Well, t82, they were a cruel lot in those days - what we now think of as S & M might just have been an ordinary, recreational event for them!! ;))

Elizabeth I was certainly an Alpha female and she dominated the men at her court. She never married either, probably because she couldn't bear the thought of sharing her power or being told what to do by hubby:))

Jean, some historians say that James VI was sensitive about his paternity - but like a lot of history its open to speculation.

16

Carol,

30/09/2006 14:21:29

Bet the English don't come out well in the film though. Good job Mel Gibson ain't it in, in it?

17

Carol,

30/09/2006 14:22:56

oops trying to be toooo clever! So that should read - ain't in it, in it?

18

Kitti Kat,

usa 30/09/2006 14:26:35

If Hollywood gets this one historicaly correct it will indeed be a rare event. I remember all too well the movie with Vanessa Redgrave and Glenda Jackson. Why would two talented actresses (especially British actresses who should have refused to act in something concerning history that was false) -the movie was dreadful. Can't see this new model being much better. Those of us who are older remember the fiasco of Hollywoood doing the Agatha Christies Miss Marple and Poirot - the actors chosen were awful as well as all the changes in the original story made. In my book, David Suchet and Joan HIckson were the most "realistic" characters. HOpe I'm wrong about this latest Mry film but i rather dobut it. Hollywood could ruin an ant's picnic.

19

Kitti Kat,

usa 30/09/2006 14:29:23

sorry about typos. The carpal tunnel syndrome is really bad today. Someday I will get disgusted enough and have the surgery. Call me "chicken".

20

primbun,

The South of USA 30/09/2006 17:30:16

Wasn't Rizzo suspected of being gay? Not that that precludes him fathering a child, of course.

I used to be quite fascinated by Mary as a young girl, read the Lady Frazier book and all. I've always thought Mary was hotter than Elizabeth. The Redgrave/Jackson movie prompted the only sex education my parents ever gave me because it was rated PG (parental guidance). They asked me if I "knew". I said, yes, that I "knew". End of discussion and we went to the movie. Hope this new movie is a good one. Personally, I prefer historical accuracy, too.

21

Joanna,

Cambs 30/09/2006 17:59:22

Kathy @ 20

James VI and I was also believed to have homosexual tendancies even though he fathered 9 children, of which only 3 survived infancy, to his wife Anne of Denmark.

James had close and documented relationships with two young men: Robert Carr, the son of Sir Thomas Carr or Kerr of Ferniehurst. According to contemporary reports James fell in love with the young man, and as the years progressed showered Carr with gifts. The other was George Villiers, the King wrote to Villiers: "I desire only to live in this world for your sake... God bless you, my sweet child and wife, and grant that ye may ever be a comfort to your dear dad and husband." James bestowed a multitude of honours upon Villiers, culminating with creating him Duke of Buckingham.

There has always been speculation about James VI and I's sexual tendancies.

22

Great Scott.,

Canada 30/09/2006 18:19:24

John Knox and the 'Lords of the Congregation', were determined to overthrow a 'female monarch'and a Catholic as according to Puritan Theology it was against the law of God.
They used the Biblical Queen Athalia as a basis for their construct.
Athalia supposedly had usurped the throne of Israel after all the King's sons had been killed except for one,who had been saved by his nurse and kept in the Temple until he was ten.The Temple Priests then produced him, proclaimed him King, and ordered Queen Athalia to be killed.
John Knox used this story of the Bible to reason it was acceptable to murder a man in cold blood,and depose an anointed Queen.
The plot against Rizzio was known in England a month before it happened.Cecil,Robert Dudley,and Walsingham did not warn Queen Mary, although the French got wind of it and warned her but the warning came too late.
The noble 'Lords of the Congregation,' wanted to keep Mary imprisoned until the birth of her child,crown him King,and dispose of her.Lord Ruthven was against this plan he said"It will only be another girl".
Queen Mary was very fortunate not to have been butchered along with Rizzio.
John Knox was implicated in the murder of Cardinal Beaton long before the return of Queen Mary to Scotland.
He would be very much at home with the Taleban.
I think the BBC could make a good film with a British cast.Keira Knightley as the young Mary and Rachael Stirling as Queen Elizabeth would be interesting.

23

Steve Evans,

Malta 30/09/2006 19:04:57

Who could cast as John Knox ? Billy Conolly would be quite good, although if he were still alive I think Dave Allen would have been fantastic!!!

24

Joanna,

Cambs 30/09/2006 19:32:20

John Knox could be played by Robert Carlyle - I think he'd be pretty good in the role :))

What about Bothwell? We need a sexy leading man for him ............ how about Viggo Mortensen - he always looks good on a horse (for the ride to Dunbar)!

25

Doreen,

Glasgow 30/09/2006 19:33:16

Was Mary Queen of Scots fortunate not to have been butchered? seems to me she was, it took several blows before her decapitation was a success. By her death mask it would appear that she was quite an attractive woman, pretty even. Perhaps she was the 'Diana' of her day, or wanted to be.

26

Steve Evans,

Malta 30/09/2006 19:53:53

Joanna, Bothwell ? How about Ralph Fiennes and Elizabeth ? Kristen Scott Thomas. Don't forget Walsingham, Essex, Duke of Norfolk, Darnley, FrancoiseofFrance, Mary of Guise the list is endless and would probably go well over Hollywoods budget..Ava Maria!!!

27

Joanna,

Cambs 01/10/2006 11:32:07

Johnny Depp for Darnley - he could play an English dandy to perfection - he'd probably steal the film. Alan Rickman could play Mary's illegitimate half brother, James Stewart, Earl of Moray because he's good at villians.

28

Great Scott.,

Canada 01/10/2006 17:15:31

Doreen 25: I agree with your comment.Perhaps I ought to have rephrased that to,"James 6th was fortunate that his mother was not killed when Andrew Ker of Fawdonside's pistol misfired when pointed at her abdomen." But I do know what you mean about her execution.

29

primbun,

The South of USA 02/10/2006 00:14:28

John Knox would fit in perfectly here in the land of the Bible Belt. There are plenty of people around here that still think like him (sadly enough)!
I know Billy Conolly can be a serious actor, but I really picture him as a satirical Pythonesque John Knox! Michael McFadyen from Pride and Prejudice would be a nice Bothwell.

Thanks for the info! : )

30

Steve Evans,

Malta 02/10/2006 05:50:51

Has Hollywood taken any note these recent comments ?


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.