Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 21st November 2009

Iain Morrison: Taking one game at a time, but half an eye still on 2011

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 08 November 2009
SATURDAY WILL mark a milestone in the rehabilitation of Scotland's new coach when he leads a team in his first Test match for three years. He looked dead and buried back in 2006 when Argentina beat his England team 25-18 at Twickenham. Robinson declined to walk the plank, and 17 days later he was forced out.
The next three weekends will test the coach's abilities with three very different opponents, from Fiji's extravagance to Argentina's brute forward strength. All three (Australia are the other opponents) are ranked above Scotland and it promises to be
an intriguing series. While three victories are conceivable, three losses are not impossible in which case any fans in the vicinity of the coaches' booth at Murrayfield had better come armed with ear plugs.

Robinson is both passionate and vocal. He always had too much energy to lie down for long and his reputation has recovered swiftly. The little Englishman dragged Edinburgh to their best ever league finish and he oversaw the Scotland A team triumph 67-7 against Ireland in 2008 before leading them to the Nations Cup last summer. The only blot on his copybook occurred in the Heineken Cup where Edinburgh won a meagre four matches in 12 outings on his watch.

It is worth returning to that "A" team victory over Ireland in Perth since it represents the distillation of Robinson's rugby philosophy made flesh. He won't reach those heights very often but that performance is what he is always aiming at. On the day his team played at a tempo that veered just the right side of frantic. The home side attacked with the ball in hand, constantly changing the point and angle of attack, and they were aggressive in everything they did. Robinson likes aggressive players, which is why at least one Lamont brother will turn out next week, if not both.

On the field that day, largely out of favour with the senior squad, were the likes of Graeme Morrison, Ben Cairns, Simon Danielli, Moray Low, Al Kellock, Phil Godman, Alan MacDonald, Johnny Beattie, Ally Dickinson and Max Evans, who treated the crowd to a brace of tries and a backflip to celebrate. Many of those same faces will appear in Scotland's full team in the next three weeks and those that don't are probably injured.

You don't have to search with a magnifying glass to find cracks in the Scotland squad but this team also has several notable strengths. The run-on pack will boast ball-playing, athletic forwards and there will be strike runners lurking in the wide channels who will score tries if the inside backs can buy or steal them a yard or two of space.

One thing that Robinson learned from his fraught time as England's head honcho is never to look too far ahead, concentrate on the here and now, win the next match and let next week look after itself.

He will do just that but pundits can't help but peek ahead at the overall race for the 2011 Rugby World Cup in New Zealand and ponder who has stolen an early march. Despite their poor season, Robbie Deans has blooded several impressive youngsters for Australia, France have found Maximes Medard and Mermoz to pin their hopes upon and New Zealand are behind only South Africa in world rugby despite missing the twin cornerstones of their pack in Carl Hayman and Ali Williams. Wales and Ireland are short just one, maybe two, pieces of the jigsaw to be world class, only England continue to underwhelm.

Three years ago, their manager Martin Johnson called for Robinson's resignation but red hot irons would not persuade the Scotland coach to return the favour now or indeed anytime in the future, despite the fact that the current management had won just five from 12 matches after yesterday's disappointment at Twickenham.

Closer to home, giving game time now to Scottish youngsters such as Alex Grove and Moray Low should pay dividends when 2011 rolls around. Scotland are in reasonable shape but will be better served when Ross Rennie, Simon Taylor, Ally Dickinson, Euan Murray, Jim Hamilton, Fraser Brown and others return to press their claims.

Meanwhile the immediate danger lies in investing a little too much emotional capital in the national coach, who is no miracle worker. Robinson has done extraordinarily well to date but the real challenge starts on Saturday and that, as he is fond of reminding everyone, is why they are called Test matches.

Iain Morrison's XV to face Fiji: R Lamont; S Lamont, Morrison, Grove, Danielli; Godman, Cusiter; Jacobsen, Ford, Low, Hines, Kellock, Strokosch, Barclay, Beattie.



Page 1 of 1

 
1

RDW,

08/11/2009 08:52:10
Anyone any idea who Fraser Brown is??
2

thebigiam,

08/11/2009 10:12:31
If Ian is right, and this turns out to be Robinson's first side, then we should give him credit for going down the radical path of picking two locks. Though this means no place for Jason White.

The other thing I notice is that there is no place for Thom Evans. My first thought was that he must be injured, but if he is fit and Danielli is in on form, then that would suggest a bit of depth in that position.

No Paterson either; but for me, I think that is the right call. Despite his kicking, commitment to the cause, and other qualities, I don't think he's the best full-back in the squad.

Here's hoping that the Robinson era gets off to a good start. And the discovery of an attacking edge to Scotland's play.
3

Stoobing,

London 08/11/2009 12:23:58
Agree with Morrison's team by and large, but can't help thinking I'd rather see Rory Lamont on the wing and - gulp - Southwell at 15. He's playing well for Stade and is a far better kicker from hand than R Lamont.

Thom Evans form seems to have dipped but I agree with 2 that I'd rather see him start for Scotland, esp as Danielli is on the bench for Ulster now.
4

JT,

08/11/2009 14:08:33
Lets hope that there is fire in the belly of the players. Thats whats been missing for a number of years and I think Andy Robinson is bringing that back. As for selection, all being well Paterson should feature.
5

Dan Dare & the Mekon (we're frae ooter space, ken),

Ooter Space, ken? 08/11/2009 17:44:56
There must be concerns for the financial future of the SRU and of Scottish rugby more generally in light of the governing body's recent well-publicised current or impending sponsorship difficulties, involving the probable departure of one-time key commercial partners such as Canterbury, Murray International and Bank of Scotland Corporate.

Moreover, assuming the SRU's banking arrangements are now effectively in the hands of the same bailed-out Lloyds Banking Group which is presently controlling the destiny and purse-strings of Glasgow Rangers FC, the Union's operational position with two wholly-owned yet highly uneconomic professional teams looks to be increasingly fragile going forward.

All this, when there are indications that Murrayfield's top mandarins may sooner or later be moving on....

Strangely, such a situation ought to provide a final, once-and-for-all "last chance saloon" platform for (possibly new) management to step in to reshape and sympathetically realign the organisation in a manner that recognises and properly addresses the real needs of its principal stakeholders, the SRU's member clubs.

DD & M
Ooter Space - ken?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.